By cyrus_pinkney
![]()
I recently purchased a 1750 sf 1950s raised ranch that’s currently being heated by its original, oil
American Standard boiler that’s also supplying my
DHW. We have recessed cast iron rads on the main living floor, with cast iron baseboards in the basement. Considering oil prices being what they are, we’re very much interested in replacing the system that’s currently operating at around 60% efficiency…which is probably being generous.
I have been shopping around for the best replacement setup for our needs, which I should outline now; we’re a young couple that have intentions of having children and possibly expanding the home down the line. The 6 gallon tank inside our boiler is barely supplying enough hot water (shocker) to our 2.5 baths. We have not even attempted heavy demand; 2.5 baths + dishwasher + clothes washer would be impossible to run within a few hours of one another. Being that it’s juts the 2 of us now and we’re already running out of water after consecutive showers, we’re hoping to eliminate the limited supply of hot water. The original, single-paned slider windows are still throughout the house, which will also be replaced eventually, but not before the boiler installation. Insulation throughout the house is average at best. The existing boiler is tied into a fireplace chimney in our basement that keeps us from utilizing the area in front of the fireplace (the oil boiler sounds like a jet when it kicks on), so we are also intending on installing the new boiler elsewhere in the basement, in all likelihood direct vented. When I purchased the home, there already was a 3/4″ gas line piped to where a dryer would go and where we were thinking about relocated the new system to–more on that below.
What does helps us is that I am an architect and pretty handy, so my intentions were to replace the boiler myself to help with my budget, which is a factor. Alsom, to pay for college, I was a plumber’s apprentice for a few summers and winters, so I am not really intimidated by the job, but rather making the right decision for my home for the next 30+ years. I have generated a manual-J for the house in Wrightsoft that is giving me around 67k BTU heat loss, so I am thinking of around an 80k BTU for a replacement. I was planning on a blower-door test, but I already know the house won’t fair all that well considering the windows and doors.
We’ve spec’d Navien combis units on a few buildings we’ve done in some urban multi-family buildings in northeast NJ which have given us nothing but trouble, but we believe it has a lot to do with shoddy installation. Our plumbers from that job has complained about the difficulty of getting Navien reps to take care of their issues and overall below average customer service. With that being said, I am still open to their product, just with a
Source: DoItYourself.com